Showing posts with label Amir Muhammad. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Amir Muhammad. Show all posts

Monday, March 12, 2007

'Apa Khabar Orang Kampung': Right to Think is a Democracy

I have read Dr Azmi Sharom's article in Malaysia Today / The Star. The title is "The Right to Think"

He claimed he is sick with the attitude of those in power, who chose to censor the 'Apa Khabar Orang Kampung' or 'Village People Road Show' movie due to so-called "Communist Propaganda"
In reality, the aforementioned movie is just a documentary detailing the views of the last remaining Malay Communists still alive and seeking refuge in Thailand.

Despite such censorship from local authorities, this movie had opened in many international screens such as Berlin Film Festival and Singapore.

I agree with Dr. Azmi, we have a right to think.

After all , a right to think is a democratic principle ...

If Malaysia wants to steer itself towards a Developed Country, we need to establish a culture that encourages thinking and discussion.

It should be that, rather than encouraging downright elitist attitude that controls the mindset of the people for personal gains.

Banning this movie equals to restricting the freedom of speech and the right to think.

I have a question to ask the so-called democratic powers-that-be in Malaysia:

"Isn't such attempt to restrict a form of Communist governance?"

Please practise what you Preach...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Two Cents Argument with Sipuntum on 'Apa Khabar Orang Kampung' Ban

Previously Amir Muhammad's latest documentary-movie about Malay Communists were banned by the Malaysian Censorship Board due to 7 reasons

Amir Muhammad had just submitted a letter with 14 reasons to explain and to counter the 7 by Malaysian Censorship Board.
____________________________

A blogger had posted this:
Sipuntum wrote:
I watched his short films overseas before. my two cents, government is quite right to ban this film. Most of his films are not suitable for general audience in term of script and I can't see any 'good' moral behind it.My advice to filmmakers, when you make a film, you need to think what is your contribution to the society? Can the society get your message? It's so unethical to make the film just for money, or kind of your 'art work'..end of days, the society become even more confuse..it's your obligation...my two cents anyway...
27/02 16:02:18


Below is my comment in the Malaysia Today article "Amir appeals against 'Apa Khabar Orang Kampung' ban".

Dear Sipuntum,

Argument: "Most of his films are not suitable for general audience in term of script and I can't see any 'good' moral behind it."

1) Not all stories released by Malaysia censorship has "good" moral. Therefore your argument that "not having good moral" type of story should be banned is invalid. Furthermore, this movie is for age 18 above viewers, not for general viewership.

Argument: "My advice to filmmakers, when you make a film, you need to think what is your contribution to the society?"

2) Knowledge is a form of contribution to the society. Society needs to know the truth, opinions and listen to both sides of story on independence. "Apa Khabar Orang Kampung" is to detail what the Communists think about their homeland and struggle. Therefore it is ethical and useful to Malaysia.

Argument: "It's so unethical to make the film just for money, or kind of your 'art work'"

3) "Lelaki Komunis Terakhir" was a critically acclaimed movie. Expectedly, it failed to succeed commercially in a big way (not the big money-making type). As for the "art work", I do not understand how you can describe it as unethical when it is just filming down what people think about certain incidents?

Argument: "end of days, the society become even more confuse..it's your obligation"

4) If the society becomes more confused, it would mean there are certain parties twisted the truth about the independence. Maybe what you read in the text book was twisted. Maybe the people in the movie twisted the stories? However, that does not mean we should believe only one side of the story, which is the text book and disregard the other.

IT IS AN OBLIGATION FOR ANY FAIR-MINDED INDIVIDUALS TO ALWAYS SEEK THE TRUTH than being spoon-fed and accept whatever materials that one party gives.

IT IS AN OBLIGATION FOR an ethical filmmaker to seek the truth and contribute it to the society, which I think Mr Amir Muhammad is doing quite well.

My two cents worth is, please, think from a big angle. Do not narrow your perspective. Do some research before giving any two cents worth of opinion. Try to do some research before coming to a conclusion. Do not smear someone without any proper points.

Thanks and Regards..

Feel free to post comments....

Friday, February 23, 2007

"Apa Khabar Orang Kampung" Banned !

Finally the ban has come !

Ladies and Gentlemen,

You can read the 7 reasons given by Malaysia Censorship Board for banning this film.

You can view the trailers in Da Huang Pictures and Amir Muhammad's Blog

Apa Khabar Orang Kampung Blog is here. Seems that Berlin Film Festival and Singapore will be running this. Fret not, my dear bloggers, we can always purchase the DVDs in Singapore. This is not a surprise considering the fact that we do not get to see certain U-Wei's Cannes award winning films in Malaysia.

Let me repost what I wrote on 19th December in Malaysia Today, here:

==start==========================
MALAY COMMUNISTS, DO THEY EXIST?
================================

It is true that some Chinese fight against Communist too but not all Malays are not communists!
However, please bear in mind there are CHINESE COMMUNISTS who are still living:
(Lelaki Komunis Terakhir)

There are also MALAY COMMUNISTS who are still living:
(Apa Khabar Orang Kampung: Sequel for Lelaki Komunis Terakhir)
(Malaysia Kini description on the sequel)

They are staying in Ban Chulabhorn Pattana 12 or the 12th Chulaborn Development Village, not far from the Narathiwat-Kelantan border.

The 10th Regiment Leaders are Shamsiah Fakeh and Ibrahim Chik. Their memoirs were published by penerbit UKM website before:

Picture taken from Penerbit UKM. There are some description for the "Memoir: Shamsiah Fakeh" book.


Picture taken from Penerbit UKM. There are some description for the "Memoir: Ibrahim Chik" book.

There was some mention (not sure how true it is) that the books were eventually "frozen" by Penerbit UKM although the books were not banned by Internal Security Ministry:

SO, as much as there were Chinese Communists, THERE WERE MALAY COMMUNISTS TOO.

==end===========================

Additional notes of personal opinion to add (23/02/2007):

1) By fighting against the Japanese TOGETHER, Malays and Chinese Communists actually made Malaysia independent from foreign powers. The communists were praised for the resistance.

2) British came back after the Japanese left. They wanted this land for their own. Communists go against the British. British labels Communists as villains. Wiping out process begins.

Doesn't this strategy sound familiar?

3) So, what is UMNO's role in fighting against Japanese and British for this country's independence? How much have they contributed? This questions leaves much to your own research and imagination for answers.

4) Try to grab a copy of December 2006 "The Edge" Magazine (not newspaper). The mentioned copy has Muhiyiddin as the cover boy. There are pictures of the Malay communists as well as some of their opinions inside.

I have bought it and shall try to search for it. If I still have it with me, I shall scan the pics and put in on my webpage.

5) The English translation for "Apa Khabar Orang Kampung" is "Village People Road Show". The Bahasa Malaysia title is named after Sudirman's famous song.

6) Zainuddin Maidin tried to play racial cards on the so-called "Chinese Communists" last year. Please do not do it again here. Read what he has said and what I have commented

================================